best fish fry madison

Best Fish Fry in Madison: A Friday Night Tradition

Madison, Wisconsin, boasts a vibrant culinary scene, and one tradition stands out above the rest: the Friday night fish fry. Finding the best fish fry in Madison is a quest undertaken by locals and visitors alike, with numerous establishments vying for the title. This article explores some of the top contenders and what makes them stand out.

Why Fish Fry is a Madison Staple

The fish fry tradition in Wisconsin is deeply rooted in its history and culture, particularly among its Catholic communities who abstained from eating meat on Fridays, turning to fish as an alternative. As explained in more depth on Wikipedia’s article about Fish Fry, this practice evolved into a social event, with churches and taverns serving fried fish alongside sides like coleslaw, potatoes, and rye bread.

Top Fish Fry Destinations in Madison

The Old Fashioned

The Old Fashioned consistently ranks high on “best of” lists. They offer a classic Wisconsin experience with their beer-battered cod, served with tartar sauce, coleslaw, rye bread, and your choice of potato. The atmosphere is cozy and reminiscent of an old-time supper club, adding to the overall appeal.

Jordan’s Big Ten Pub

Jordan’s Big Ten Pub offers a very casual atmosphere where you can indulge in their lightly battered fish fry, with a choice of cod or perch. Known for its generous portions and laid-back atmosphere, it’s a popular choice for a relaxed Friday night.

The Avenue Club and Bubble Up Bar

For a more upscale experience, The Avenue Club offers a sophisticated take on the fish fry. Their perch fry is a standout, praised for its delicate flavor and crispy breading. The ambiance is chic and modern, perfect for a special occasion.

Dexter’s Pub

Dexter’s Pub features a traditional deep fried cod fry. Often recognized as a local favorite with a casual and friendly atmosphere.

Tips for Finding Your Perfect Fish Fry

Consider these factors when choosing a fish fry: fish type (cod, perch, walleye), batter style (beer-battered, breaded), sides (coleslaw, potato pancakes, fries), atmosphere, and price point. Also, call ahead to check availability, as some places can get crowded on Friday evenings. Fish fries are usually a limited-time offering only available during the evening, primarily on Fridays.

Frequently Asked Questions

What kind of fish is usually served at a Madison fish fry?

Cod and perch are the most common types of fish served, but you may also find walleye, bluegill, or other varieties depending on the restaurant.

What sides are typically served with a fish fry?

Common sides include coleslaw, potato pancakes or fries, tartar sauce, lemon wedges, and rye bread.

Are fish fries only available on Fridays?

Yes, traditionally, fish fries are a Friday night tradition.

Do I need reservations for a fish fry?

While not always required, it’s recommended to make reservations, especially for popular restaurants, as they can get very busy on Friday evenings.

How much does a fish fry typically cost?

Prices vary depending on the restaurant and the type of fish, but you can generally expect to pay between $12 and $25 for a plate.

In Summary

Madison’s fish fry scene offers a diverse range of experiences, from casual pubs to upscale restaurants. Whether you prefer classic beer-battered cod or delicate perch, there’s a fish fry to suit every taste. Explore the options and discover your own personal favorite in this beloved Madison tradition.