indianapolis colts first round picks

Indianapolis Colts First Round Draft Picks: A History of Success and Setbacks

The Indianapolis Colts have a rich history of drafting impactful players in the first round of the NFL Draft. From future Hall of Famers to players who didn’t quite pan out, the Colts’ first-round selections tell a story of both shrewd decisions and unfortunate misses. Examining these picks provides insight into the team’s roster-building strategy over the years.

Notable First-Round Successes

The Colts have landed several franchise cornerstones in the first round. One of the most notable is, of course, Peyton Manning, selected first overall in 1998. Manning led the Colts to a Super Bowl victory and earned multiple MVP awards. Another impactful pick was Edgerrin James (1999), a dominant running back who ranks among the Colts’ all-time leading rushers. More recently, Quenton Nelson (2018) has solidified the offensive line, earning multiple All-Pro selections. These picks demonstrate the Colts’ ability to identify and acquire elite talent early in the draft.

First-Round Misses and Disappointments

Not all first-round picks live up to expectations. Bjoern Werner (2013) was selected with the 24th overall pick but failed to make a significant impact on the defense. Similarly, Trent Richardson (2012), acquired via trade after being drafted by Cleveland, was a major disappointment at running back. These instances highlight the inherent risk associated with drafting, even with high picks. Player evaluation can be an inexact science, and sometimes, players simply don’t translate their college success to the NFL level. More historical data about previous drafts can be found at Indianapolis Colts Draft History.

Recent First-Round Selections

In recent years, the Colts have focused on addressing key needs with their first-round picks. In 2023, they drafted Anthony Richardson 4th overall, hoping to secure a long-term solution at quarterback. These selections reflect the team’s current priorities and their assessment of the available talent pool. Only time will tell whether these picks will achieve the same level of success as some of the Colts’ earlier first-round selections.

FAQs

What is the highest draft pick the Colts have ever had?

The Colts have had the first overall pick multiple times, including the selections of Jeff George (1990), Steve Emtman (1992), Peyton Manning (1998), and Anthony Richardson (2023).

How many Hall of Famers have the Colts drafted in the first round?

The Colts have drafted several Hall of Famers in the first round, including Peyton Manning and Edgerrin James. More players may be inducted in the future.

What positions do the Colts typically target in the first round?

The Colts have historically targeted quarterbacks, offensive linemen, and defensive players in the first round, depending on their roster needs at the time.

Who was the Colts’ first-round pick in 2022?

The Colts did not have a first-round pick in 2022. They traded the pick to acquire Carson Wentz the previous year.

How do the Colts decide who to draft in the first round?

The Colts’ draft strategy involves extensive scouting, player evaluations, and analysis of team needs. They also consider factors such as player character, potential, and fit within their system.

Summary

The Indianapolis Colts’ history of first-round draft picks is a mix of triumphs and setbacks. While some selections have become franchise legends, others have fallen short of expectations. By examining these picks, we can gain a deeper understanding of the challenges and rewards of drafting in the NFL and the Colts’ overall approach to building a competitive roster.